@uzbyuksalish

Telegram

@uzbyuksalish

en

Public dialogue: challenges, problems and achievements in the system of internal Affairs bodies

 2020-06-24 15:41:27   |     Просмотров: 5294

Open discussion, opinions and suggestions, and constructive criticism characterize the public dialogue. The first meeting in this format was devoted to the issues of preserving the socio-political situation and stability in the context of the coronavirus pandemic.
The next one, which took place on June 24, was devoted to discussing aspects of respect for the rights and freedoms of citizens by employees of internal affairs bodies, preventing cases of abuse of authority and violence, formulating proposals for the development of their activities, expanding civil participation and interaction of the population with law enforcement agencies.
The public dialogue organized by Nationwide movement "Yuksalish", National Association of Electronic Mass Media and public activists brought together representatives of NGOs, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, analytical centers, parliamentarians, lawyers, journalists, bloggers and specialists of state agencies on one platform.
It was noted that recently the number of reports and materials about illegal actions of employees of internal affairs bodies has been increasing in social networks and mass media. In particular, the case of the death of a resident of Andijan after he visited the administrative building of the city Department of Internal Affairs, caused a wide response among the public. Although, from the point of view of legislation, a solid foundation has been created for the protection of human rights and legitimate interests.
Thus, the law "On internal affairs bodies", which came into force in March 2017, established that the internal affairs bodies carry out their activities on the basis of respect for the rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of citizens. An employee of the internal affairs body is forbidden to resort to torture, violence, or other cruel or degrading treatment. An employee of the internal affairs body is obliged to prevent actions that intentionally cause pain, physical or moral suffering to a citizen.
By Presidential decree of April 10, 2017 (https://www.lex.uz/docs/3159825) provided for a drastic increase in the effectiveness of the internal affairs bodies, strengthening their responsibility for ensuring public order, reliable protection of the rights, freedom and legitimate interests of citizens. The document also approves a Program of comprehensive measures to fundamental reform the system of internal affairs bodies, and a special Commission was formed to implement it, headed by the Minister of Internal Affairs. One of the key directions of reforming the system of internal bodies of the Republic defined their transformation into public service oriented professional, whose activities should be aimed at providing timely and quality care to the population, the unconditional implementation by each employee of his duty — "To serve the interests of the people."
On April 4, 2018, the Head of the State signed a law on making a number of amendments and additions to legislative acts aimed at taking measures to strengthen guarantees of citizens' rights and freedoms in judicial and investigative activities. One of its innovations was to increase the responsibility of law enforcement officials for the use of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment.
In accordance with the decree of the President of December 13, 2019 "On additional measures to ensure the supremacy of the Constitution and the law, strengthen public control in this direction, as well as improve the legal culture in society" (https://lex.uz/ru/docs/4647340), starting from April 1, 2020, a mandatory procedure for videotaping actions of detention of a person, explain his procedural rights, and refuse a lawyer was to be introduced. From the same date, law enforcement officers, after detaining a person, are obliged to immediately notify one of their family members of their detention and place of custody, and, in their absence, other relatives or close persons.
However, not all norms of the current legislation are effectively applied in practice, including due to lack of openness and transparency of law enforcement, full control by the public and Parliament, relatively low level of adoption of modern technologies (in particular, systems for audio and video recording of investigative action in all internal affairs agencies of the Republic).
At the same time, a number of participants believe that it is not necessary to belittle the achievements of the entire system of internal affairs bodies. Thus, the most important step in Uzbekistan's commitment to human rights was the closure of the “Zhaslyk” colony in August last year. At the time of closure, 395 convicts were being held in the 1,100-seat prison, of which 10 per cent were criminally responsible for religious extremism.
The period of detention of persons suspected of committing a crime has been significantly reduced (from 72 to 48 hours), and the maximum period of detention as a preventive measure has been reduced (from 12 months to 7 months). The new approach demands that preventive detention is applied as a measure of last resort, arrest is excluded from the penal system and introduced a new form of punishment in the form of compulsory community service.
It is important to keep in mind the risks of injury or death in the line of duty. There is also a reverse side of the coin — the personal responsibility of citizens in fulfilling their obligations and complying with the established rules and regulations. In particular, there are many cases of some citizens ignoring the requirements of quarantine during the pandemic and other regulations.
Participants noted that issues of security and ensuring the rights and freedoms of citizens directly affect not only the mood in society, but also the image of Uzbekistan in the international arena, maintaining its position in a number of international ratings.
Based on the results of the public dialogue, practical proposals and recommendations were developed, in particular, to improve the interaction of internal affairs officers with citizens, and to involve the civil sector more widely in improving the efficiency, transparency and accountability of law enforcement agencies.

Insights from the participants:

Akmal BURKHANOV,
Chairman of the Nationwide movement “Yuksalish”:

— We should admit that one part of our citizens does not trust the internal affairs agencies, and some are even afraid of them. Less and less positive image is formed when it comes to an employee of the internal affairs bodies. In Uzbekistan, large-scale reforms are being implemented in this area, as in a number of other areas. Unfortunately, today some situations in different regions of the Republic undermine the image of the internal affairs bodies. Illegal actions of individual employees cause a wide response among the public. This negates all the positive changes made in the system. Our goal is to give an objective assessment, analyze the current situation, convey to the public the true nature of the problem, share suggestions and recommendations for their solution.


Ulugbek MUHAMMADIEV,
Human Rights Commissioner of the Oliy Majlis of the Republic of Uzbekistan (Ombudsman):

— Recently, the President signed a decree approving the National Human Rights Strategy of the Republic of Uzbekistan. The decree approved the "road map" for the implementation of the National Strategy. According to the “road map”, the procedure for videotaping the detainee with an explanation of his procedural rights and refusal of a lawyer is introduced.
Also, it includes the issue of imposing on law enforcement agencies the obligation to inform close relatives of the detainee, if they are not present, then other relatives. For example, in Andijan, when a citizen was taken to the Department of Internal Affairs, no one was informed, and his relatives did not know his whereabouts. This situation should not be! All processes should be legal, as in developed countries. In other words, relatives should be informed about whether a citizen has been detained, where he is, and what charges have been brought against him.

Shokhrukh GIYAZOV,
press Secretary of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Uzbekistan:

— In 2019, 28 employees of internal affairs bodies were killed in the line of duty, and 229 were injured of varying severity. Please note that only 20 employees were killed and 81 injured while ensuring road safety.
In the first five months of this year, five more people were killed and 73 were injured. Among them, 4 dead and 31 injured — employees of the road safety service.

Gulrukh AGZAMOVA, Deputy of the Legislative chamber of the Oliy Majlis:
— When we have problems, we are waiting for legal protection of employees of bodies of internal affairs. However, recently, what is the level of trust in them? The Presidential decree of 2017 criticized the system of internal affairs bodies, identified more than ten shortcomings and problems in their activities, as well as proposals for their elimination. It is noted that "To serve the interests of the people" is the unconditional duty of every employee. What will happen to citizens in the future if the current state of the system and its internal problems are not resolved? Will people's level of fear increase when they stop trusting the internal affairs agencies? Another problem that concerns me is that the children of a citizen who died as a result of being beaten by law enforcement officers were orphaned. Now his widow will not be able to awaken in children warm feelings for the profession of a law enforcement officer, it will be difficult to change the negative attitude to representatives of the sphere. It is time to pay more attention to these aspects in the Legislative chamber and develop appropriate regulations.

Press service of the Nationwide movement " Yuksalish»